Will the Carolinas Protect Their Citizens From the Next Flood? — Hurricane Florence Update
A changing climate will bring more storms and flooding events, we must enact 21st century solutions that protect families and our communities.
** Editors note — this post was updated on 10/3/2018 with new information post-Hurricane Florence
Hurricane Florence brought its full force to bear on the Carolinas. Winds of 100+ miles per hour caused wide-ranging damage, but the biggest impacts of this slow-moving storm were from rainfall – up to 3 feet in some areas. Record flooding occurred in southeast North Carolina and northeast South Carolina, flooding which persists in some areas almost 3 weeks after the storm.
The loss of human life, damage to infrastructure and displacement of whole communities are staggering:
- 48 lives lost – 39 in North Carolina and 9 in South Carolina
- 840 road closures including portions of Interstate 40, Interstate 95 and other major highways
- All-time record flooding of the Black, Cape Fear, Lumber, Neuse and Waccamaw rivers
- 61,000 people requesting disaster relief according to the NC Department of Public Safety
- $1.2 billion in federal disaster funds requested by South Carolina’s governor
- Several breaches of Lake Sutton Dam that resulted in coal ash being spilled into the Cape Fear River
- 11 dam failures in South Carolina including 5 significant hazard dams
This makes the fourth year in a row that the region has been walloped by tropical cyclones. Will 2019 be the fifth? Unfortunately, the blog’s message is just as relevant today as it was a year ago or the year before that. Hurricanes are more frequent, getting stronger and lasting longer according data from NOAA’s Earth Systems Research Center and reported by The Guardian. We have endured 15 above normal hurricane seasons during the past 24 years – a record. State elected officials in the Carolinas must take immediate and substantial steps to better prepare for the future hurricanes that climate change will bring.
—Original Blog from 10/6/2017 below —
Harvey. Irma. Jose. Maria. Is there an end to the alphabet soup of 2017 hurricanes affecting the Southeast and our citizens in the Caribbean islands? Most of the focus has been on other states and territories – Texas, Florida, the US Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico – and deservedly so as those areas have suffered devastation of historic proportions. We are somewhat fortunate in the Carolinas to have been spared the worst of the cyclones’ wrath this year and that no “rain bombs” caused dams to fail as with Hurricane Juaquin and Matthew. Yet often overlooked is that five people died in South Carolina due to Hurricane Irma, homes and businesses flooded, and life is not back to normal for many people along the Carolina coast.
This makes the third year in a row that hurricanes have blown past the Carolinas.
Final damage and economic impact estimates from Irma are still not known. We do know that 2015 and 2016 hurricanes and resulting floods combined damaged more than a quarter million homes, caused 93 dams to fail and, most tragically, resulted in the loss of 52 lives. The 2015 floods are South Carolina’s second most costly environmental disaster causing more than $12 billion of damage and economic impacts. Hurricane Matthew and its floods rank among North Carolina’s top environmental disasters with an estimated $2.8 billion dollars of property damage and $2 billion in economic impacts.
For decades scientists have been warning us that a warmer climate will bring more frequent and more violent storms to the Southeast. While the models are complex the concept is simple. Warmer temperatures evaporate more water adding more moisture to the atmosphere. This leads to more precipitation and more large storms.
That is exactly what has impacted the Carolinas for three years in a row. Will 2018 be the fourth?
There is no doubt that flooding is becoming more frequent and more severe.
The impacts of floods out rank all other natural hazards and predictions indicate that the size of nation’s floodplains will grow by 40 to 45% by the end of the century putting even more communities in harm’s way. We must adapt to changing conditions to ensure the safety of our citizens, their homes and our roadways from increasing storms and floods.
The political leaders of the Carolinas have largely ignored decades of warnings from scientists relying instead on a business-as-usual approach to floodplain development, poorly planned growth and dam safety. North Carolina actually outlawed the use of climate science for evaluating future sea level rise.
Will the lives lost, property damaged and dams failed be enough to convince the states’ leaders that we cannot continue business as usual?
Here are commonsense solutions to adapt to increasing floods that both states should put in place to save lives and protect property.
- Protect and restore floodplains: Naturally functioning floodplains store floodwaters and reduce downstream flooding. We need to take advantage of these natural defenses.
- Get people out of harm’s way: Poorly planned growth has allowed development in flood prone areas, putting people in harm’s way. We need to replace developed areas with green spaces that can absorb floodwaters and buffer communities from damages. Charlotte, Milwaukee and Davenport, Iowa have been leaders in taking 21st century approaches for water and flood management.
- Strengthen state dam safety laws and programs: Ninety-three failed dams make it clear that our current standards, especially for earthen dams which are by far the most likely to fail, do not provide safety with the reality of today’s extreme flooding.
- Remove dams that do not meet safety requirements: We cannot wait until dams fail to take action. Poorly maintained and improperly designed dams need to be removed to protect downstream communities and infrastructure before they fail.
The leaders of the Carolinas must learn from the hurricanes and disastrous floods of the past three years, and enact 21st century solutions that protect families from future floods. We must adapt to changing conditions and cannot continue business as usual while lives are lost and our communities are devastated.
5 responses to “Will the Carolinas Protect Their Citizens From the Next Flood? — Hurricane Florence Update”
Very in depth article about just how dire the situation is in the Carolinas with regard to flooding. One of the main things that has to happen to stem the floods is to reign in developers like Wacamaw Land and Timber that seem to have no regard for public safety and common sense and are only concerned with profits gained from developing properties whether they might be in a flood zone or not.
Our federal and state disaster relief agencies, as well as insurance companies….need to compensate people EXTRA if they choose to rebuild their homes OUT OF riverside floodplains and river deltas. (after flood events).
Seasonal / springtime riverside flooding is completely natural and healthy for millions of fish, birds, amphibians, reptiles and other wildlife that thrive in riverside floodplains and river deltas.
Attempts to control riverside flooding through dams and river-water diversions is extremely destructive to our riverside eco-sytems and fisheries.
A better solution is passing legislation which creates financial incentives to develop and rebuild OUT OF riverside floodplains and river deltas after flooding disasters…..and penalties and/or severe restrictions on new development WITHIN riverside floodplains and river deltas.
Imagine a world 100-200 years from now where riverside floodplains and river deltas worldwide have been liberated from development and these wetlands are returned to gamefish and seasonal cultivation……and any housing remaining in floodplains is built on elevated pylons…..and only accessible by boat.
We could once again be the nation which supplies the world with fish.
Imagine our rivers and oceans teaming with pre-colonial gamefish numbers….when early colonist arriving in the Americas described our east coast rivers so heavily populated with enormous fish during spawning season…..that the rivers became unnavigable by small boats.
The recent destruction of insect and bee numbers which pollinate our crops…..could also be linked to riverside floodplain and river-delta destruction worldwide….because of dams and river-water diversions…..for cities and desert agriculture.
Remember that river deltas, riverside floodplains and coastal mangrove forests….are the nurseries for much of the world’s river and ocean gamefish.
This makes sense, I wonder if some good realistic analysis showing how spending money on infrastructure ( i.e. reparing dams to safe standards, removing unsafe ones, and taking other steps to alleviate impacts of future flooding) would be less expensive then having to deal with desasters. How much less would FEMA have to spend if some money had been spent on infrastructure improvements. And then there is the personal economic disater of the people impacted.
Can’t a case be made to our individual elected officials showing common sense and proven economics?
Can we not get rid of the crazies in Washington and get our recovering environment bacK? It was healing until we got the current mob in power. We cannot go ahead with “business as usual” anymore!
Article right on target!! It’s time that we incorporate common sense into our development, floodplain and dam management. Stop further floodplain development. Move, instead of replace, frequently flooded homes. Bring existing dams up to safe levels or remove those no longer serving a purpose and prone to failure during floods.