Major Fishery Threatened by Proposed Alaska Mine

Pebble Mine would be disastrous for Bristol Bay and the fishermen who rely on it. Take action before June 27th to help protect this world-class fishery!

This guest blog was written by Katherine Carscallen and is a part of our blog series on America’s Most Endangered Rivers® – Rivers of Bristol Bay, Alaska.

As I type this blog, I can feel my fingers sting with layers of cuts and grime. Looking at my Band-Aid and grease saturated hands, I’m reminded that it was never my intention to be a mechanic. In no way do I mean to disparage mechanics, I’m often gratefully indebted to them. It’s just that I grew up on my parent’s commercial fishing boat.

Suncet fishing on Bristol Bay. | Elsa Sebastian

I was always drawn to the bridge of the boat, watching the net go out, fish pile in, and my favorite part, picking each fish out of the net, one by one as they come aboard. Picking fish is a race against yourself, to get the salmon out as quickly as possible while taking care to remember that each one will end up on a person’s plate in the near future.

Fishing to me was always intense. Exciting. An adventure. And of course when we were lucky – lucrative.

It wasn’t long after college I knew I wanted fishing to be a permanent part of my life and I bought my boat. That was my first inadvertent step towards becoming a mechanic. I learned very quickly that in order to do the fun parts of fishing, you must first ensure your engines, hydraulics, steering, pumps, and every other detail of the boat is maintained to run without fail at a critical moment. Without all the equipment we depend on running well, I would never have the opportunity to put my net in front of the world’s largest runs of wild salmon year after year in Bristol Bay. So, this time of year, with an estimated 51 million salmon only a week or two away, I guess I am a mechanic, anxiously awaiting my chance to be a fisherman again.

Author Katherine Carscallen and her fishing Crew. | Elsa Sebastian

When I decided to make fishing my career, I also never intended to become an environmental advocate.

By the same token however, the un-paralleled fishing here in Bristol Bay is only possible thanks to generations of people caring for the habitat that sustains our salmon. Centuries ago, healthy salmon runs were all over the West Coast, unobstructed by dams, sediment, roads and other inevitable side effects of industrialization.

Today, those runs are diminished, and Bristol Bay is now unique. It’s the last great wild sockeye run in the world, and the habitat that sustains our watershed has not been damaged by development. Keeping our fishery intact means advocating for the habitat that sustains it.

Ever since a Canadian company called Northern Dynasty proposed to build what would be one of the largest mines in North America just upstream from my home in the headwaters of our two most important salmon rivers, I’ve become an environmental advocate too.

Today, the Pebble Mine is closer to becoming a reality than ever before. Northern Dynasty has entered the federal permitting process. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is taking comments on the impacts the mine would have – this is the first phase in the permit application’s environmental review.

Fishermen rely on the rivers of Bristol Bay and their world-class fishery. | Elsa Sebastian

I’ve already submitted my comment, asking that the Army Corps consider the downstream impacts this mine would have. I asked them to consider the generational threat a toxic tailing dam would pose, the economic harm the existence of a mine would have on our fishing industry that is rooted in quality, sustainability and pristine wild salmon. I asked them to prioritize thousands of years of tradition and a way of life sustained by the people of this region, and to consider the permanent and irreversible harm this mine would bring to an otherwise unaltered watershed, as one mine after another was built on top of our salmon nursery.

This is our opportunity to take a different path than the places where salmon runs have already been decimated. We can still prioritize water, salmon, people and Bristol Bay’s world-class fishery.

So, while I anxiously await the coming salmon, I’m taking a break from my boat work to ask you to submit a comment as well. Please support the last great wild sockeye fishery, and the pristine habitat that sustains it.

Please join American Rivers in asking the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to defend indigenous peoples, commercial fishermen, wild salmon and clean water by rejecting Pebble’s mining permit application.

Sign-on by June 27th to be included in our petition!


Author:  Katherine Carscallen

Katherine Carscallen is a commercial fisher woman and lifelong resident of Bristol Bay.

6 responses to “Major Fishery Threatened by Proposed Alaska Mine

  1. You do realize the proposed Pebble mine is 100 miles away from Bristol Bay itself, essentially int he middle of nowhere, don’t you? Since Pebble is in permitting and be subjected to the rigorous process under NEPA and its true impacts on the environment are being evaluated using real science, will you support the mine, if the process and the mine plan determines that there is no impacts to the fishery?

    Somehow, after reading your article, I rather doubt it Katherine. God forbid a proven to be safe mine, creating thousands of good year-round paying jobs up in Alaska, is of any real interest. Fishing only goes so far, and good hard working people have families to raise and have put food on their tables. Povertly, Unemployment, alchhol ad drug abuse, and crime are the real enemies, not this mine.

    If you want a real story, I challenge you to get the facts, talk to the company, and learn about the mine plan, what it is what they are doing and the details of it, get involved, instead of just assuming it is bad.

    https://www.pebbleprojecteis.com

    https://www.northerndynastyminerals.com

  2. NDM is according to you “just upstream”. It is over 100 miles away. That is not close as you imply. NDM has submitted a reduced mine foot print and is not using cyanid. The tiny streams that are close by don’t even run half of the year and account for less than 1% of the water suppling Bristol Bay. Pebble would be in the middle of no where and the mine will boost Alaska’s economy while giving many jobs to the locals.

    Why don’t you try some investigating and fact finding before you spew these lies to the uninformed. You should be ashamed of yourself

  3. I did not bother reading your article because the environmental impact study is not even done yet so how will you know the impact of the mine? Environmentalists want science to dictate development yet you won’t wait for the study that will let SCIENCE determine the outcome.

  4. hmm, just up the road huh. Seems like 100 miles is a little farther than that. Maybe you could drive your boat up there, that’s right, no river running up there. so what else we got, oh yeah, company has vowed to not use cyanide, acid generating rock will be returned to the mine, to alleviate acid and the perpetual care that is involved with it. so where are these toxic tailings coming from that the communist NRDC have been coaching you on for so long.
    how about, we take %15 of your fishing earnings and distribute the folks living in nondalton and illamna. They can’t necessarily ride their boats down to Bristol bay and catch fish. kind of where the whole plane accessible only thing came from. I guess they could go down to BB and work for a WA state boat captain who bought some poor Alaskans fishing permit. But its a very, and I do mean very, short fishing season. Maybe if we quit catching all the fish in the mouth of the rivers, we could have bumper crops of them in the years ahead.
    The people from the BB fisheries seem to only care about themselves and live in very secluded worlds. Northern Dynasty has done everything feasible to make a smaller, environmentally friendly mine. Yet the constant yammering from you folks is the fish will die, seems to me the fish are dying from fisherman catching them, and the infamous BLOB that has snuck into the pacific and really hampered the copper fishery.

  5. Wow! This piece shows a real bias and lack of understanding as to what the pebble mine is proposing: A clean modern state of the art mining facility that will bring infrastructure, jobs and goods, while posing no threat to “nearby” waters(100 miles away).
    Clearly, some activists just like being activists.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.